I got this shirt in red and love it. It's soft, it's long enough, and it's not see-through (the picture of the black shirt made me wonder if it was transparent -- the red, at least, is lightweight but opaque.) I have large shoulders and button-ups rarely work on me, but this one did. The length of this shirt is perfect for me. Not too short.
The only thing is that there's a ridiculous tag sewn on below the buttons and it shows. It has the Hurley logo on it and just looks like it belongs on the inside of the shirt. Be careful if you cut it off -- it can be done, but it's painstaking work.