I'm rating these initially and I'll come back at the end of the season and do a full review.
Just got these today and the initial quality is great. I got an XL and normally wear a L, so they're nice and baggy, not technine Chris Bradshaw baggy, but nice and roomy. Like I said I'll use them for the next two months and then actually review them.
Okay, its mid March and I've ridden these pants probably 10 times or so. So far so good. I've ridden in rain and spring slush and stayed dry. The styling and functionality is very good for a pant of this price range.