The good...I really love the fit and the style of these shorts. They're short but not too short. Love the stretch in the material. Love the colors (I got the Vintage Blue). The materials is soft and super comfie. I usually where 32s and got the 32s and they were spot on.
The bad... These have the worst fly ever. There's a small gap below where the waistband ties but there's no velcro to completely close the fly--kind of like boxer shorts. It's really odd. I actually had somebody sew a piece of velcro there for me. Also, they're light colored and the material doesn't seem to clean very well. Granted, I took them on a river trip and got them pretty dirty but it seems that most board shorts would clean up better.