I bought these jeans in all four colors. The fit depends on the color you buy which might be why some of the reviews I've read for these jeans are so different. For that reason I'm rating them four stars. You would think they would all fit the same.
I think the silver and raw pair fit perfectly. They are a slim fit without being skin tight. The black pair are a bit baggy in comparison and seem a tad longer than all the others. The indigo pair are the tightest for sure. I won't be wearing them if I plan on eating a big meal that day. If you like your jeans skin tight then go for the indigo pair. So I guess there is a pair for everyone here.
Silver - Slim fit without being skin tight
Raw - Slim fit without being skin tight
Black - A bit on the baggy side in comparison
Indigo - Skin tight fit