I loved these gloves for the most part until my right glove began to fall apart after only 5 days on the mountain. The inner seam came apart and continued to tear every time I put on or removed the gloves. I think I just got a bad glove because the left hand held up well. Other than that.....my hands always stayed dry and warm. I still give a 3/5 because they are great gloves I just got a lemon pair.